Tooth Fairy ideas beyond the coin

A lost tooth is a small milestone that comes round twenty times. A few rituals make each one feel special without it getting expensive.

Make it together, free

A letter from the Tooth FairyPersonal, with which tooth it was and what they did to lose it. Ratoncito Pérez or La Petite SourisIn Spain, Latin America and France a mouse collects the teeth.

Under $20

A tooth pillow or box. Somewhere safe to leave it, and a place for the letter.
Glitter footprints. A little fairy dust on the windowsill.
A gold coin for the first one. A bigger moment for the first tooth only.
A tooth chart. Record which tooth and when, and keep it in the Grow Book.
A book about the Tooth Fairy. Read it the night the tooth goes under the pillow.

Questions people ask

What can the kids make for the kids?

A letter from the Tooth Fairy — Personal, with which tooth it was and what they did to lose it. It is free on Keepers of Childhood.

What is a good A lost tooth gift under $20?

A tooth pillow or box. Somewhere safe to leave it, and a place for the letter.

Never miss it again. Add your husband or partner on your account and we’ll email them before A lost tooth with ideas like these. Set up reminders.

Nobody pays to appear on this page, and there are no shop links.

The homemade ones, ready to print

Every “make it together” idea above prints from a free account — letters, scrapbook pages, photo signs and coloring pages. It remembers your children’s names so you are not retyping them, and it costs nothing.

A free account, not a trial. No card, and we will not email you about anything you did not ask for.