Keepers of Childhood Keepers by The Compendium Company, LLC

Blog · November 18, 2026 · 6 min read

First Lost Tooth Ideas: Ways to Mark the Big Night

The easiest first lost tooth ideas are small ones: take a gap-toothed photo, let your child pick a safe spot for the tooth (a pillow pocket, a tiny box, a saucer of water on the nightstand), and leave something back overnight with a short note. Most kids lose that first tooth around age 6, usually a bottom front one 12, and the national average left per tooth was $5.01 in 2025 3, so a coin or two plus a few handwritten lines is plenty. Pick one or two ideas, not ten, and repeat whatever you choose for the next tooth so it becomes your family’s tradition.

What to do in the first ten minutes

The tooth usually comes out somewhere inconvenient: a sandwich, the school bus, the bathtub. Stay calm and make a little ceremony of it, because your reaction sets the tone. If there’s a bit of blood, the usual advice is a rinse with cool water and gentle pressure on the gap 8, and anything that worries you is a question for your dentist.

Dentists generally say to let a loose tooth come out on its own. Tugging a tooth before it’s ready can mean breakage, bleeding, and soreness 4, so let your child wiggle it with a clean finger or tongue and wait it out. Crunchy snacks like apple slices do the job better than any doorknob trick.

Then do the fun part right away, while the gap is new:

  • Take a big grinning photo, straight on, so you can see the gap.
  • Rinse and dry the tooth, then put it in a small container with a lid. A pill box, a ring box, or a square of foil all work.
  • Write the date on a sticky note and stick it to the container. You will forget otherwise.
  • Let your child call a grandparent and announce it. This is a bigger thrill than anything you can buy.

Nine ideas for the night itself

You don’t need a kit or a costume. Choose one thing that you can do again next time without groaning.

  • A tooth pillow with a pocket, so nobody has to fish under a sleeping child’s head.
  • A glass of water on the nightstand instead of a pillow. The tooth sinks, and by morning there’s a coin at the bottom and the water has turned faintly green or blue from a single drop of food coloring.
  • A tiny door taped low on the baseboard, with the tooth left on the floor in front of it.
  • A sprinkle of glitter or a dusting of flour with one small footprint pressed into it.
  • A coin wrapped in a scrap of shiny paper, like a very small present.
  • A “receipt” for the tooth: tooth number one, condition excellent, brushing rating five stars.
  • A tooth chart taped inside a cabinet door, with a sticker added for each tooth that goes.
  • A special breakfast the next morning, which costs nothing and gets remembered for years.
  • A short letter from the Tooth Fairy that mentions something only your house knows.

How much to leave, and what else works

Money is the most common choice, and the amount matters less than consistency. Delta Dental’s 2025 Original Tooth Fairy Poll put the average single lost tooth at $5.01, down about 14% from $5.84 the year before 3. Plenty of families leave a dollar, or a quarter, or a special coin.

Whatever you pick, write it down somewhere you’ll find it in six months. The first tooth sets the price for nineteen more, and kids compare notes with siblings and friends. If cash isn’t your thing, these stand in nicely:

  • A foreign coin or an old coin from the year your child was born.
  • A single new book, a pack of stickers, or a glow-in-the-dark star for the ceiling.
  • A “ticket” for one trip to the park with you, no siblings.
  • A tiny pouch to hold the next tooth.
  • A letter and nothing else, which works better than parents expect.

Writing the letter (the part kids keep)

The coin gets spent. The letter ends up in a drawer and gets read again at nine, at twelve, and at thirty. A good one is short, specific, and a little funny.

Name the tooth. Say where it came out and what your child was eating. Mention the wobbling that went on for a week. Compliment the brushing, promise to take good care of the tooth, and sign off in a hurry because there are other houses to get to. Four or five sentences is perfect, and messy handwriting in a color you don’t normally use is part of the charm.

If you’d rather not fake the handwriting at eleven at night, you can make a personalized Tooth Fairy letter with your child’s name and the details of this particular tooth, or read what to write in a Tooth Fairy letter for lines you can borrow.

Where the tradition comes from, if your child asks

Paying a child for a lost tooth is old. There was a Norse custom of the tand-fé, or tooth fee, paid when a child lost a first tooth, recorded as far back as the Poetic Edda 5. The fairy we know is much newer: she turns up in a 1927 play by Esther Watkins Arnold and in a 1949 children’s book by Lee Rogow 6.

Other families have other visitors. In Spain and much of Latin America it’s a mouse, Ratoncito Pérez, and in France it’s La Petite Souris, who swaps the tooth for a coin in much the same way 7. In parts of India, Japan, Korea, China, and Vietnam, children throw a lost lower tooth up onto the roof and tuck an upper tooth below, so the new tooth grows toward the old one 7.

If your family has roots in one of those traditions, use it. A letter from Ratoncito Pérez or La Petite Souris lands differently than a generic one, and it gives your child a story about where they come from.

Keeping the tooth and the memory

Decide now what happens to the actual tooth, because “I’ll deal with it later” turns into a tooth rolling around a junk drawer. Some parents keep every one in a labeled box. Some keep the first and quietly retire the rest. Both are fine.

Teeth keep coming out until around age twelve, when the back molars finally go 12, so you have years of this ahead. Snap the gap photo each time and note the date and which tooth, and you’ll end up with a strip of photos that shows a whole face changing.

A lost teeth scrapbook page holds the photo, the date, and the story for each tooth in one place on your phone, so the note on the fridge isn’t the only copy.

When it doesn’t go to plan

Someone swallows the tooth. Someone wakes up at 5 a.m. to find the tooth still there. Someone asks, point blank, whether you are the Tooth Fairy. All of this is normal, and none of it ruins anything.

A swallowed or lost tooth is easy to fix with a note saying the Tooth Fairy found it anyway, or with a drawing of the tooth left in its place. A missed night is easy to fix too, with a believable reason and a little extra. A direct question deserves a question back: “What do you think?” Most kids tell you exactly how much magic they still want.

There’s more help in what to do when a child swallows a tooth, what to do if you forgot the Tooth Fairy, and when kids stop believing.

A five-minute version for tonight

If the tooth is already out and bedtime is in twenty minutes, do this and call it done.

  • Photo of the gap, taken now.
  • Tooth in a lidded container, date written on it.
  • Tooth under the pillow or in a cup of water.
  • One coin and four handwritten sentences, delivered once your child is asleep.
  • Same routine next time, so it becomes the way your family does teeth.

Questions parents ask

What age do kids lose their first tooth?

Most children shed the first one around age 6, usually a bottom front tooth, and teeth keep coming out until about age 12 12. Earlier or later than that is common, and your dentist can tell you what’s typical for your child.

How much does the Tooth Fairy leave for a first tooth?

Delta Dental’s 2025 poll put the national average at $5.01 per tooth 3. Many families leave a dollar or a special coin instead. Pick an amount you can repeat for every tooth, because the first one sets the standard.

Should I pull a loose tooth?

Dentists generally say to let it fall out on its own, since pulling early can cause breakage, bleeding, and soreness 4. Let your child wiggle it with a clean finger, and ask your dentist about any tooth that worries you.

What if my child is scared of losing a tooth?

Name what’s happening, show them the new tooth already pushing up, and let them hold the tooth afterward. Reading about other kids’ first teeth helps, and so does letting your child decide where the tooth goes for the night.

Do we have to do the Tooth Fairy at all?

No. Plenty of families mark the tooth with a photo, a special breakfast, or a note from a parent. A mouse visitor, such as Ratoncito Pérez or La Petite Souris, is the tradition in many homes too 7.

Sources

  1. When Do Children Start Losing Their Baby Teeth?. HealthyChildren.org (American Academy of Pediatrics), 2025.
  2. When kids lose their first tooth: What to do, how early, and more. Medical News Today, 2025.
  3. The Tooth Fairy’s on a Budget: 2025 Original Tooth Fairy Poll findings. Dentistry Today, 2025.
  4. When to Pull a Loose Tooth. Colgate, 2025.
  5. Tooth Fairy Magic: Tooth Fairy Timeline. Sindecuse Museum of Dentistry, University of Michigan, 2025.
  6. The origins of the Tooth Fairy. Clinique Dentaire Charles Trottier, 2025.
  7. 7 Different Tooth Fairy Traditions Around the World. Dental Care Centre GP, 2025.
  8. What To Do When Your Child Has a Loose Tooth. Chestnut Dental, 2025.

Keep reading

Free, always

The printables that go with this

Scrapbook pages, photo signs, coloring pages and letters from the keepers of thirty traditions — all free to print. A free account remembers your children’s names and keeps the pages you fill in.

A free account, not a trial. No card, and we will not email you about anything you did not ask for.