The Lantern Keeper

The story

He is not a ghost and he is not frightening, though he keeps company with things that are. He walks the lanes at dusk on the last night of October with a taper, lighting the carved lanterns one by one, and he is still out long after the children have gone in. He is said to be fond of the fierce faces and to take a professional interest in the carving.

Where it actually comes from

The carved lantern comes from Ireland and Scotland, where turnips and large beets were hollowed out, given grotesque faces and lit, then set in windows and doorways on Samhain to ward off wandering spirits. Irish immigrants to North America found the native pumpkin far bigger and vastly easier to carve, and it replaced the turnip almost completely. The name comes from the folk tale of Stingy Jack, condemned to wander with only an ember in a hollowed turnip — Jack of the Lantern. Samhain itself marked the end of harvest and the start of winter, when the boundary between worlds was held to be thin.

What it does for a child

Halloween is many children’s first deliberate, voluntary encounter with being frightened, and that is genuinely valuable — fear approached on your own terms, in costume, with an exit and a bag of sweets, is how children learn that being scared is survivable. Explaining that the lantern is a guardian rather than a threat reframes the scariest object on the doorstep as something on their side, which helps a good deal with the ones who find the night too much.

Jack and the Turnip Lantern

A story to read aloud · about 4 minutes

Long ago in Ireland, at the edge of a wide, wet bog, there lived a boy named Jack. Jack was the cleverest boy in the county. He could talk a crow out of a cherry, people said, and a goat out of its hat. He was a bit of a trickster, it is true. But his tricks were mostly the laughing kind.

Now, out on the bog there lived a wisp. It was a small, silly, flickering light that bobbed over the water on dark nights. The wisp loved nothing more than a game. When travelers came walking home late, it would dance ahead of them, calling, “This way! This way!” and lead them round and round in circles until their boots were full of mud.

It was not a wicked thing, only a mischievous one. But it made the dark nights very long.

One cold evening at the end of October, when the nights are longest of all and the old people say the world feels thin as a curtain, Jack came home from the market with a sack of turnips on his back. The wisp came bobbing up beside him.

“This way, Jack!” it sang. “This way!”

Jack only smiled. “You’re a grand little light,” he said. “But I’ll wager you’re not bright enough to fill a turnip.”

The wisp flared up, offended. “I can fill anything!”

So Jack took out his knife, hollowed a turnip in a trice, and held it open. “Prove it.”

In the wisp popped. And Jack, quick as a wink, set the top back on.

“Let me out!” squeaked the wisp.

“I will,” said Jack, “on one condition. Tonight, instead of leading folk astray, you’ll light them home.”

The wisp grumbled. But it was warm and snug inside the turnip, much cozier than the cold bog. So it agreed. Jack carved two round eyes and a big grin in the turnip’s side, and the wisp’s light shone out through them, golden and cheerful.

All that night, Jack walked the bog road with his turnip lantern held high. He found a farmer who had lost his way and walked him to his gate. He found a peddler stuck in a ditch and lit the way out. He found a lost lamb and carried it home under his arm.

And a strange thing happened. The wisp liked it. It liked the way people smiled when they saw the light coming. It liked hearing “Thank you, Jack!” and “Bless that lantern!” By morning, it did not want to leave the turnip at all.

So it stayed. And every year after that, on the last night of October, Jack and his lantern went walking the dark roads together, lighting the way for anyone who needed it.

The people of Ireland and Scotland began carving turnip lanterns of their own and setting them in their windows, so that any traveler walking past would see a friendly face and know that home was near. Children dressed up in costumes and went from door to door with their lanterns, and nobody got lost at all.

When families from Ireland sailed across the sea to America, they found that pumpkins were bigger and much easier to carve than turnips. So they carved pumpkins instead. And that is why, to this day, a glowing, grinning pumpkin is called a jack-o’-lantern.

So this Halloween, when you see a jack-o’-lantern shining on a doorstep, give it a little wave. It is only Jack’s old friend, the wisp, doing what it learned to love best: lighting the way home.

An original Keepers story, grounded in recorded folk custom.

However they look at your house

No two families picture The Lantern Keeper quite the same way. Here are six of them.

Read more